When embarking on dissertation research, students often encounter the term “ontology”—a fundamental concept in philosophy and research methodology. Understanding ontology is crucial, as it shapes the foundation of research design, influencing how researchers perceive reality and construct their studies.
What is ontology?
Ontology is a branch of philosophy concerned with the nature of reality and existence. In the context of research, ontology refers to the researcher’s assumptions about what exists in the world and how these elements interact. These assumptions guide the methodological choices made throughout a study.
It is often categorized into two broad perspectives:
Realism – The belief that reality exists independently of human perception. Realists assume that objective truths exist and can be discovered through empirical research.
Relativism – The perspective that reality is socially constructed and subjective, varying across different individuals or groups based on experiences and interpretations.
The relationship between ontology and epistemology
Closely linked to ontology is epistemology, which refers to the theory of knowledge—how we come to know what we know. The ontological stance of a researcher influences their epistemological approach, which in turn affects their research methodology. For instance:
- A realist ontology aligns with positivist epistemology, favoring quantitative methods such as surveys and experiments to discover objective truths.
- A relativist ontology aligns with interpretivist epistemology, leading researchers to employ qualitative methods like interviews and thematic analysis to explore subjective experiences.
The role of ontology in dissertation writing
Ontology plays a crucial role in dissertation writing by shaping various aspects of the research process:
Defining Research Questions
- A realist ontology leads to research questions that seek to measure objective phenomena (e.g., “What is the impact of social media on academic performance?”).
- A relativist ontology results in questions exploring subjective meanings (e.g., “How do students perceive the role of social media in their learning?”).
Choosing Research Methods
- A quantitative approach is typically favored by realists, using statistical analysis to validate hypotheses.
- A qualitative approach suits relativists, using thematic or narrative analysis to understand different perspectives.
Interpreting Findings
- Realists aim for generalizable findings applicable to broader populations.
- Relativists accept that findings are context-specific and subject to different interpretations.
Establishing Research Validity
- Realist-oriented dissertations emphasize reliability, objectivity, and replicability.
- Relativist-oriented studies focus on credibility, reflexivity, and the authenticity of participant experiences.
More like this: Understanding axiology and its impact on dissertation writing
How to identify your ontological position
As a researcher, reflecting on your ontological stance is essential before designing your dissertation study. Ask yourself:
- Do I believe in an objective reality that can be measured, or do I see reality as constructed through human interactions?
- Am I more comfortable analyzing numerical data, or do I prefer exploring narratives and meanings?
By answering these questions, you can align your research approach with your ontological perspective, ensuring coherence in your dissertation structure and argumentation.
Follow us on X @BeInTheKnow_UK
