Job interviews are nerve-wracking for most of us — whether it’s your first or your fifteenth. But there’s one mistake that consistently sinks even the most promising candidates: winging it.
Winging it during a job interview might feel like the easiest option when you’re short on time, brimming with confidence, or just tired of preparing. After all, you know your own experience, right? How hard could it be?
Well, harder than you might think.
Let’s break down why “winging it” is a mistake — and how you can walk into any interview with clarity, confidence, and the kind of preparation that helps you stand out.
Why winging it fails
It shows — and not in a good way
Interviewers can tell when you’re unprepared. Rambling answers, vague examples, or long pauses while you think of something to say are all red flags. It suggests a lack of respect for the process and a poor work ethic.
You miss key opportunities
Every question in an interview is a chance to align your skills with the company’s needs. Without preparation, you’re less likely to deliver structured, persuasive responses that highlight your value.
You can’t “wing” company research
Interviewers often ask what you know about their business, mission, or products. If your answer is generic, it’s obvious you didn’t care enough to do the homework.
Confidence ≠ Preparation
Being good at talking doesn’t guarantee you’ll say the right things. Overconfidence often leads to missed talking points or tone-deaf responses.
Practical ways to avoid winging it
Know the job description inside and out
Start by reading the job posting line by line. Highlight keywords, required skills, and responsibilities. Ask yourself:
- How does my experience align with this?
- Can I think of real examples to match each bullet point?
If the job calls for “strong project management,” don’t just say, “I’m good at managing projects.” Be ready with a story that proves it.
Pro tip: Turn each requirement into a question. For example: “Tell me about a time you led a project under a tight deadline.” Then rehearse your answer.
Prepare your core stories
Instead of trying to memorize exact answers, prepare 4–6 “core stories” from your past experience. These stories should cover:
- Leadership
- Problem-solving
- Teamwork
- Handling conflict
- Achieving results
- Learning from failure
Use the STAR method:
Situation, Task, Action, Result — it gives your story structure and makes it easier to follow.
Once you have these stories, you can adapt them to fit a wide range of questions.
Research the company like a pro
Go beyond the “About Us” page. Look at:
- Recent news or product launches
- Their social media presence
- Employee reviews on sites like Glassdoor
- Their mission, vision, and values
Understanding the company’s culture and current goals helps you tailor your answers. It also enables you to ask meaningful questions — more on that later.
Tip: Mention something specific you learned. For example:
“I saw that you recently expanded into the healthcare sector. That aligns well with my background in medical data analytics.”
Practice out loud
Reading your answers in your head is not the same as saying them out loud. Practice in front of a mirror, with a friend, or record yourself.
This helps you:
- Catch awkward phrasing
- Refine your tone and pacing
- Build confidence
You don’t need to memorize answers word for word — but you do need to be fluent in your own story.
More like this: Common job interview presentation mistakes (and how to avoid them)
Anticipate the tough questions
Prepare for common and difficult questions like:
- “Tell me about yourself.”
- “What’s your biggest weakness?”
- “Why are you leaving your current job?”
- “Why should we hire you?”
These are rarely the place to improvise. Prepare thoughtful, authentic responses that reflect both humility and self-awareness.
Ask smart questions
Near the end, the interviewer will usually ask, “Do you have any questions for us?” This is not the time to ask about salary or perks (unless it’s a second or third round). It’s your chance to show curiosity and strategic thinking.
Great questions might include:
- “How does this role contribute to the company’s long-term goals?”
- “What challenges is your team currently facing?”
- “What does success look like in the first 90 days?”
Avoiding winging it here shows that you’ve done your research and are seriously invested in the opportunity.
Follow us on X @BeInTheKnow_UK
